Belgian Malinois and German Shepherds have been confused for too long. Despite the fact that they were herding dogs and a similar color, they share many physical and behavioral differences. Finding the right pet or even a service dog can be a challenge in and of itself, but understanding what awaits you can go a long way.
Do you know how to tell the difference between the two breeds? Who has more triangular ears? Which one is the best family dog? Let’s find out!
Comparison of the Belgian Malinois and the German Shepherd
See the difference between the Belgian Malinois and the German Shepherd. Although both dogs are intelligent and active, they have several differences in appearance that make them easier to separate.
Belgian malinois | German Shepherd | |
---|---|---|
Life span | 12-14 years old | 10-13 years old |
Ear shape | Triangular | Pointed tips |
Coat coloring page | Solid and consistent | Bicolor |
Tail | Angular | Poofy |
6 main differences between the Belgian Malinois and the German Shepherd
Although the German Shepherd is widely regarded as the best dog for the police, both breeds exhibit many exceptional qualities. They look quite similar in appearance, which is partly the reason they are so often confused. However, health problems and personality traits make them very different from each other. Let’s take a look at some of the general differences between the two breeds.
Belgian Malinois vs.German Shepherd: coat coloring
At first glance, the Belgian Malinois and the German Shepherd seem to be quite similar, but their coloration is the most important clue to which one is which. Although the Belgian Malinois are lighter or fawn in color, they have a black mask with black ears.
The German Shepherd, however, has a darker coloration all over its body, mixing black and dark blond fur together. Sometimes this breed has a coat of three or more colors.
Belgian Malinois vs.German Shepherd: A little muscle goes a long way!
The difference in size between the two breeds is primarily related to their muscle mass. The Belgian Malinois is tall and thin. Their muscles seem to be more designed for speed, they run at speeds of up to 30 miles per hour in their compact size.
Belgian Malinois males often weigh less than 60-80 pounds, while the German Shepherd usually weighs up to 90 pounds. Most of their large size is associated with impressive muscle mass, which the Belgian Malinois simply do not have.
Belgian Malinois vs.German Shepherd: Man’s Best Friend? Not always!
The main reason so many people seem to love dogs is because they can become “man’s best friends,” and the German Shepherd is a great example. These dogs have a loyal and gentle disposition, although their physique is quite massive. They tend to be gentle and affectionate, which sometimes makes them bond so strongly with their masters that separation anxiety quickly goes away.
The Belgian Malinois is very different from others as it thrives on its independent nature. In fact, there are people who find this breed to be almost unfriendly as they mostly go about their business. For people who may have to leave home frequently, this puppy has little to no separation anxiety. In fact, the hardest part of being away from the Belgian Malinois’ wanderlust is – instead, he might just try to take his own trip around the area!
Belgian Malinois vs.German Shepherd: Watch Out For Teeth!
Although the German Shepherd loves their family more, they are also quite rude players. Their playing time can get a little aggressive, and they are known to have a tendency to bite, bite and gnaw while playing.
Even with their independent side, Belgian Malinois may be better for some kids because they don’t really use their mouth much while playing. The chances of being bitten are much less.
Belgian Malinois vs German Shepherd: Entering the Fight
Historically, the high energy and ability to take commands have made the German Shepherd an excellent companion during combat. They are fairly easy to train to attack other people, which is probably why police officers in many states have them on staff. They were formerly used during World War II as messengers, guard and rescue dogs, and today they are still used in the military.
The Belgian Malinois, with their independence, were not used at all in combat, although due to their aggression, the police began to view them as working dogs.
Belgian Malinois vs.German Shepherd: a matter of good health
When it comes to the cost of veterinary care, each breed’s susceptibility to different health conditions is important. The Belgian Malinois appears to be the healthier of the two breeds, primarily prone to joint dysplasia and eye problems, although they can also suffer from allergies.
The German Shepherd, on the other hand, has many health problems to worry about. Along with the diseases that can plague the Belgian Malinois, this breed can also suffer from problems such as chronic diarrhea, blindness, cancer, lupus, diabetes and other problems. While the German Shepherd is likely to become a favorite among dog lovers, the cost of keeping it healthy is high.
Next: Lambs vs Sheep – 5 Key Differences
Belgian Malinois vs German Shepherd: 6 Key Differences, FAQs Explained (Frequently Asked Questions)
Is the Belgian Malinois better than the German Shepherd?
It depends on what kind of dog you want. While the Belgian Malinois may be more independent, the German Shepherd is more likely to deal with issues like separation anxiety if the owner is away for a long time. Consider your lifestyle to determine which one suits them.
Are Belgian Malinois smarter than German Shepherds?
Both breeds are incredibly intelligent. However, the tenacity and high energy of the Belgian Malinois can make them difficult to learn.
Are Belgian Malinois like German Shepherds?
The two herding dogs are strikingly similar in appearance, although they are completely different in character. The Malinois is often mistaken for a German Shepherd in appearance alone.
What is the difference between a Belgian Malinois and a German Shepherd?
While the German Shepherd has a medium length coat, the Belgian Malinois has shorter and thicker coat. German Shepherds have more health problems, while Belgian Malinois are more likely to chase their prey. These two dogs are very different species.